Teachers & Technology -- a rant!
I was on the road all last week, and since getting back home, I've been a little less focused on my blogging. So I set about this week's Tech Learning post a little less prepared than usual. Scanning back over last weeks blogs, written by my esteemed colleagues, I was most struck by Jeff Utecht's post, Fear Factor. Jeff's comments resonated with me because of several conversations I had last week with administrators and tech integrators in schools I worked for in Connecticut and Maryland.
The idea of fearful teachers came up several times, and I have to admit an increasing frustration with this issue. Why do we treat teachers so delicately? Why do we forgive them year after year for not adopting contemporary information and communication tools? Why are we satisfied with small steps?
Well, the answer is simple. Teachers are special. They are smart, resourceful, incredibly accomplished, and they work miracles -- they make a difference. They influence so many lives and they are revered. It's clear. How can we treat them with anything but awe and respect -- especially when no one really has a clear picture of what integrating technology means? If we might fast forward to ISTE's new NETS, what do creativity, innovation, communication, collaboration, research, information fluency, critical thinking, problem-solving, decision-making, and digital citizenship really look like in a technology rich classroom?
For several years, many of us have been trying to make a case for thinking about education in new ways, largely as a result of technological advancements and their affects on how we use information. I think that many education leaders are listening now. I think that they are ready for clear images and stories about 21st century classrooms and what teachers and students should be doing to better prepare a generation of new century citizens.
For me, I have to admit that I've become fairly comfortable howling at the moon. Refocusing on sharing and even inventing concrete applications will be a pretty hard corner or me to turn. But it will also be exciting.
As for the teachers? Well, I've become dissatisfied with Marc Prenski's portrayal of digital natives and digital immigrants. It's a useful distinction, but not if teachers make it an excuse not to try. I think that our children have every right to expect that their teachers will teach more from today's information landscape. If you think about it, they only taste that most children have of the 20th century, is their classrooms -- where we're supposed to be preparing them for the 21st century.
I almost lost it when I read, in Cheryl Oats' comment, "..someone told me they didn't want to learn one more new thing, they didn't like new things.." I would want to ask, "You call yourself a teacher?" Who more than teachers should be willing and eager to learn new things?
Calming myself back down again, I have to remind myself that technology is anything that was invented after you were born. Our kids, as Jeff reminds us, grew up with computers and the Internet. They become so accomplished with these tools because it's play for them. I think that I took to computers simply because I remembered playing with Legos. Perhaps we need to teach teachers to play again.
Sorry for the rambling rant!







Comments
David (tried responding on 2 cents, but kept getting kicked off just now),
Neither you nor Jeff mention the two fears that I see crippling teachers way more than any fear of the new or unknown:
1) the fear of tech administrators to even look at web 2.0. Maybe you guys run across enlightened, progressive tech administrators everywhere you go, I don't know. From where I sit, the fear of those in charge of technologies (fear of empowering teachers, fear of the unknown, fear of public scrutiny, etc.) - essentially stops the process of getting new technologies and the requisite knowledge to use them into the hands of teachers.
2) For those teachers who are out there pushing new technologies, there is clearly the fear of losing their jobs. I've seen it happen, and I do think about it - every day.
There ya go Dave - one good rant deserves another :) - Mark, a teacher
Posted by: Mark Ahlness | September 3, 2007 9:14 PM
Finally, someone's ranting about the poor technological state of many teachers. David's always in the vanguard of teachnology issues.
I would like to see more pressure on principals and superintendents. After all, the reason that teachers remain technologically illiterate is no pressure from senior administration to change.
Posted by: Patrick Greene, PhD. | September 11, 2007 7:10 PM