| Program |
Basic Suite |
Cye (Education) |
Robolab 1.5 |
TechnoK'NEX |
| Publisher |
ActivMedia Robotics
(800) 639-9481 |
Educational Robot Co.
(888) 550-7658
CYE |
Pitsco/LEGO Dacta
(800) 362-4380 |
Kýnex Education
(888) 222-5639 |
| Platform |
Windows 95 or higher and Linux |
Windows 95 or higher |
Windows 95 or higher; Mac 7.5 or higher |
Windows 3.11 through Me; Mac 7.0 through 9.0 |
| Price |
Software and manual: $395; AmigoBot: $1,795 |
Wagon, software, and Cye: $2,995 |
Starter system with 4 RCXs: $999 |
Grades 1-4: $425; Grades 5-9: $575. Multi-station kits range from $1,435 to $1,725. |
| Emphasis |
Programming, mapping, and problem solving |
Programming, mapping, and problem solving |
Invention, design, engineering, physics, and basic programming |
Invention, design, engineering, physics, and basic programming |
| Grade Level |
7 and up |
4 and up |
4 and up |
1ý9 |
| Programming Language |
Colbert, a C-type language used for the map grid; ARIA for advanced programming |
Map grid |
Icon based |
Icon based |
| Features |
ýSimulator can be purchased either with or without a preassembled, wire-free robot.
ýSoftware can run several robots remotely using the Internet |
ýComes with preassembled robot
ýBattery-powered with charger
ýMap-based programming
ýOperates without sensors
ýGraphic user interface
ýCan do relative, absolute, and polar coordinates |
ýFlexible and progressive programming modes
ýDrag-and-drop programming interface
ýTemplates for novice programmers
ýAdministrator option allows teachers to adjust RCX settings, set up files, and test transmitter |
ýActivity cards designed for new and experienced users
ýIcon-based new activity and procedure templates
ýSophisticated touch, light, and rotation sensors
ýProgram writing tools clear, undo, and save procedures
ýPicture editor personalizes icons |
| Strengths |
ýAccurate, sophisticated simulator
ýDirect or entry-level mode offers a well-paced introduction
ýVersatile mapping tool
ýSimulator alone offers an affordably priced, feature-rich programming tool |
ýTop-notch hardware and software components
ýRemarkably few glitches for such a complex package |
ýWell-designed software makes robot programming straight-forward
ýVersatile RCX doubles as microcomputer and data collection tool
ýRCX can operate without being attached to computer
ýA versatile tool with a range of building options |
ýGraduated learning modules serve as scaffolding.
ýExcellent software and design materials
ýýComputer Run Modeý debugs problem programs |
| Weaknesses |
ýComplicated manual
ýComplex tasks require advanced programming skills. |
Communicating among components is initially difficult due to unfamiliar docking mechanism |
ýHigh learning curve for complicated tasks
ýTime-consuming robot preparation and sorting of parts and materials
ýPoorly designed material storage bins |
ýCable links between computer and robot make for clumsy operation.
ýDisorganized support materials |
| Support Materials |
Teacher materials, introduction to robotics, and lesson plans |
ýGreat manual, but classroom modules have yet to be developed
ýComes with a national science and technology standards-based activity booklet |
ýAge-appropriate curricular materials, activity pack, reproducibles, and assessments
ýExtension activities at LEGO Dacta site and at the site for academic partner Tufts |
ýEducatorýs Guide, lesson building help, extensions, construction cards for building machines, task cards that outline program creation in stages, and handy quick reference cards |
| The Bottom Line |
A highly adaptable package that makes programming a challenge |
High-quality robot with well-designed software, but not yet tried and tested in Ký12 |
Robolabýs flexibility, versatility, and online support make it a great teaching tool. |
While not quite as versatile as Robolab, this program will work well with younger students. |
