The Best Defense
Everyone knows CIOs are vital to school success—right?
At the SchoolCIO Technology Summit this June, we were devastated to hear that many
superintendents still see the CIO job as tech support rather than an integral part of the district.
Even worse, some of our attendees told us they’re in danger of losing their jobs.
Take Cary Petersen, for example. This July, Petersen went from spending
eight years as executive director of IT for Jefferson County (KY) Public
Schools to becoming the manager of advanced systems. In his former role,
Petersen was in charge of all the tech support and MIS functions as well as
instructional technology. He had five direct reports and managed a team of
120 people. Today, he works on the district’s student information system,
manages state reporting, and controls some of the former technology funds.
“I’m not sure who will create the next tech plan,” he says. “I used to chair a tech
committee that did all of the planning and execution of the plan, but once the
auditors dissolved my position, the committee was dissolved too.”
Steven M. Baule, superintendent of North Boone CUSD 200 in Illinois,
says this type of restructuring has become all too common. “In the last couple
of years almost every district has had to evaluate everything. Unless you’re
seen as providing value-added services from a strategic standpoint, it’s easy to
reassign IT people to curriculum or slide it under business.”
Geoff Fletcher, deputy executive director of the State Educational
Technology Directors Association, agrees that CIOs often get shortchanged.
“When I was with the Texas Department of Education, we had to decide if you
put edtech with curriculum or with IT. What’s different now is the severity
of the budget crisis.” Fletcher advises CIOs to be vocal about what they can
bring to the table. “Technology is a part of everything. We have to let others
understand how we can help them accomplish their goals.”
“The fact that a CIO or tech director can be cut reflects the dominant
mindset that technology is not core to learning and teaching,” says Scott
McLeod, founding director of the Center for the Advanced Study of
Technology Leadership in Education. “Districts send very few messages that
technology is important from a formal policy standpoint.” McLeod knows lots
of smaller districts that outsource many aspects of technology, including web
design, web hosting, and tech support.
Time for a Turnaround
So, what can CIOs do to change the mindset and protect their jobs?
Lots of things, says McLeod. “First, you have to play the political and
marketing games as a CIO if you want to be considered essential. Make sure
others know what educational value you are adding to learning and teaching. If
you can’t point to concrete things that you do that help with targets and growth
of learning, forget it.”
Another way to prove your value is to get certified. Thanks to the
Consortium for School Networking (CoSN), that’s an
actual possibility. When members asked how to elevate the
importance and necessity of the CIO position, CoSN asked
volunteers to create the Framework of Essential Skills (see
sidebar). This document provides a list of what’s needed at
the CIO level to integrate technology into all parts of the
district. But the Framework was just the first step.
In December of last year, CoSN unveiled the Certified
Education Technology Leader (CETL) Certification
aspx). The exam has two parts. Part 1, given at proctored
sites across the country, is multiple choice and covers
the nuts and bolts of the CIO job. Part 2, which is only
offered to people who pass Part 1, is an essay-based exam.
More than 90 people have already taken the exam with
a little less than half receiving their CETL certification.
“Schools today need someone who understands the whole
educational environment and how technology brings it
into the 21st century,” says Gayle G. Dahlman, director of
certification and education for CoSN.
“Having any kind of credential won’t save you from
the chopping block, but it may give you a leg up when
you’re switching jobs,” says McLeod. “And it marks you as
someone with the knowledge, confidence, and expertise in
the CIO role.”
And that, in the words of Martha Stewart, is a good
10 Ways to Show People Your Value
1 “People in IT leadership roles have to look at their value to the organization first as an educator. This may seem obvious, but it isn’t. You have to
understand teaching and learning as well as IT. Tech is always changing but the average curriculum director doesn’t have time to be on top of
that.” —Steven M. Baule, superintendent, North Boone (IL) CUSD 200
2 “The easiest way to help people understand your value is to save money. Look at phone usage in conjunction with network capabilities or try to
save money by reevaluating your printing operation.” —Geoff Fletcher, deputy executive director, SETDA
3 “If you identify the problems on the instructional or operational side and come up with tech solutions, you become one of the most important
team members for the superintendent.” —Jean Desrvaines, CEO, New Leaders
4 “If you don’t have classroom experience, get into the classes—spend time, observe, and volunteer. Do whatever you can to understand that side
and what the needs are.” —Jon Castelhano, director of technology, Apache Junction (AZ) USD
5 “Data management is becoming more important as it’s used to measure student growth. IT people need to step up and say, ‘I’ll take care of
data.’ It increases their value immeasurably.” —S.M.B.
6 If you’re not part of the curriculum side of the house in your district, try to get in on those meetings and the planning to see what’s happening.
If it’s a cabinet, ask to be part of it.” —J.C.
7 “Be visible. The decision [to cut your job] will be made way before you hear about it. If everyone agreed it was a cut to make, then you haven’t
shown your value. You need to leave your office and be out and about.” —S.M.B.
8 “Start writing about what the tech department is doing and how it ties into the classroom. Explain the reasons behind your decisions. If your district
has a public relations person, meet with him or her. Be part of the newsletters or whatever is going out to the community.” —J.C.
9 “Today, districts buy print and digital materials, and often it’s not in a coordinated fashion. Find a way to accelerate that shift, perhaps by using
open-source resources in a coordinated way. Make a presentation so that the higher-ups understand your importance and value.” —G.F.
10 “Make sure your tech staff knows why it is there. It’s not to just fix PCs. They have to understand the importance of teacher and student
devices to be able to do their jobs effectively.” —J.C.