How Latina Educators Can Collectively Build a Path to Leadership
ALAS Summit: Collective action can elevate Latina educators to leadership roles
Collective action can elevate Latina educators to leadership roles, panelists said at the recent Association of Latino Administrators and Superintendents national summit in Denver.
“Who is it that gets to lead?” asked moderator Leslie Torres-Rodriguez, ALAS president-elect and superintendent of East Ramapo Central School District in New York. “We say that students furthest from the opportunity deserve access to it. I also ask myself, do we apply that to us as adults? Do we ask that same question, and do we create those conditions for those that are farther away from leadership to have access?”
ALAS pushes for leadership opportunities for Latina educators, said panelist Montserrat Garibay, candidate for Texas House District 49 and a former pre-K teacher and labor organizer. Garibay also outlined her method for change: identify, educate, and mobilize. If she were advocating for a dual-language program, for example, she said she would identify a group of teachers who agree the school needs the program. Next, the group would educate administrators about specific resources or professional development for a dual-language program. They would mobilize by implementing strategies or tangible actions to start the program.
Panelist Christina DeJesús Kishimoto, a three-time superintendent and past president of ALAS, said the three-step method applies to broader policy issues as well. Policy terminology might be slightly different, but leaders still need to identify the policy matter behind an issue, identify partners and determine how to network around the issue, DeJesús Kishimoto said.
The framework could also be used to approach policies related to resource equity in a school district, Torres-Rodriguez said.
“There are dimensions of resource equity,” Torres-Rodriguez said. “When we think about allocating the highest-qualified teachers, for example, to the schools that have the highest concentration of need, that's not usually the way that we apply a resource equity lens.”
District leaders could identify schools with the highest teacher turnover rates and ask how that affects performance.
Tools and ideas to transform education. Sign up below.
“The teachers are less supported. They have the highest percentage of novice teachers, and so that alone is one dimension of resource equity,” she said.
Leaders can use that information to decide where the most experienced, highest-qualified teachers should be, Torres-Rodriguez said.
A Path To Power For All
Policy can build a path to power for all women of color, DeJesús Kishimoto said, noting that her company Voice4Equity educates high-school girls across the country about policy.
“When you put high school girls together to talk about policy issues, you get out of their way. It is powerful,” said DeJesús Kishimoto.
She said she uses the same curriculum with adult female educators, who have learned to be deferential. The high school girls approach the issues without that influence.
She also encourages women of color to develop their policy voices and write books, with support from authors such as herself. “Every time I accomplish something, I turn around and say, ‘How do I pass it on?’” DeJesús Kishimoto said.
Passing it on can happen through mentorship, sponsorship, and executive coaching. Torres-Rodriguez said ALAS plays a role in these practices by providing a safe place for conversations. She also noted that mentors give advice to aspiring leaders based on their experience, executive coaches help them explore paths to leadership, and sponsors advocate for them with decision-makers.
DeJesús Kishimoto tells mentees not to be intimidated by finance or policy issues, but to learn about these and turn it into a power move.
Leadership And AI
One of the hottest policy issues in education is AI, and DeJesús Kishimoto says educators should think about it on a large scale. Discussions that are shaping AI should involve people who are voiceless and the most disenfranchised, she said.
“We’re talking about an engineering of knowledge,” DeJesús Kishimoto said, noting that the pool of people who are shaping AI is small. “What is happening in the creation of knowledge, the manipulation of knowledge, to create conflict, to create false narratives, to create false history?”
She says these broader questions will be more important in the long run than choosing which AI tools to use.
“Who has access? Who has control? Who are the developers? Who are the controllers of knowledge?” she asked, noting that the future of AI in the classroom is not a choice between human educators and AI agents. “It's about integrating what works in our communities as a resource, but not taking away the relationships that we bring.”
Educators do not need to be in an administrative role to make a difference, Garibay and DeJesús Kishimoto said. They can lead from where they are. DeJesús Kishimoto told a story about a woman from the Bronx neighborhood where she was raised. She had no formal leadership role or title, but she successfully organized neighbors any time a proposed policy wasn’t good for kids. DeJesús Kishimoto calls it “leading from the park bench.”
“The title doesn't matter,” DeJesús Kishimoto said. “Give yourself a title if you want, and just claim it.”
Garibay urged attendees to take a courageous step.
“Talk to someone you don't know, someone that you admire. Say, ‘Hey, can we have some coffee? Can we schedule a Zoom call? I want to learn about your path.’ And I assure you that they will say yes,” Garibay said.
'It's About All Of Us'
The panelists also discussed how collective action can work against multiple layers of bias. DeJesús Kishimoto pointed to layers of bias against men of color, women, people with accents, and immigrants.
“Rather than saying it's a Latina versus someone else … look at your power, look to the person who has less power on your right and bring that person along, and we will change the landscape of who has power in this country,” DeJesús Kishimoto said.
Similarly, Garibay said her work as a union leader taught her the value of collaboration and communication, including asking questions, being curious, and having courageous conversations.
More men are superintendents than women, DeJesús Kishimoto said, noting that men should provide unique professional development opportunities for women, including coaching. She said men who coach women should make sure they can also talk with a woman who has been in the role.
“We’re not fighting for you or me. It’s about all of us,” Garibay said.
Miranda Kennedy has been a journalist for more than 25 years. She lives in Colorado with her husband, two kids and two dogs, and loves to hike in the Rocky Mountains.