The Battle for Desktop Control - Tech Learning

The Battle for Desktop Control

There has long been a power struggle between techies and teachers over classroom computer desktops. IT personnel tend to believe allowing "inept" educators to have unfettered access to their computer's hard drive is an open invitation for trouble. Conversely, teachers often perceive tech support to be "uncaring"
Author:
Publish date:

There has long been a power struggle between techies and teachers over classroom computer desktops. IT personnel tend to believe allowing "inept" educators to have unfettered access to their computer's hard drive is an open invitation for trouble. Conversely, teachers often perceive tech support to be "uncaring" adversaries standing in the way of educational innovation. Who's right?

The IT Perspective

From a technical standpoint, there are many dangers to unrestricted desktop access. Shareware or freeware downloaded by teachers can slow computer performance or cause programs to not work at all. Unauthorized installation of streaming media programs and peer-to-peer file sharing software can hog valuable network space. E-mail worms also pose an ongoing threat, and even seasoned teachers may foolishly open an attachment that starts a malicious chain of damaging activity. Granted, these dilemmas are sometimes caused by students who get access to the teacher's computer. Nonetheless, they leave IT staff wishing for more desktop control and less freedom for all users.

It comes as no surprise, then, that IT staffers believe the best solution is to lock down teacher desktops. In the past, this was achieved through special security software, but now with advanced operating systems like Windows XP and Macintosh OS X, user account settings can be defined so teachers and students are protected from tinkering with the hard drives and networks they work on — for instance, installing bandwidth-taxing software or making configuration changes.

The Teacher View

For less tech-savvy teachers who stay within the comfortable bounds of known computer applications such as e-mail and word processing, desktop control is a non-issue. But when more advanced teachers are restricted from installing programs, they may literally begin pulling their hair out. These power users, who often purchase software for legitimate, educational classroom use, or experiment with promising freeware or shareware applications from the Internet, get impatient waiting for a support person to come to their classroom every time they want to install something new.

In districts that narrow usage to approved lists of licensed software titles supported on classroom computers, the situation can be equally frustrating. While license compliance is necessary and laudable, hard-and-fast rules about approved software can hamper instructional flexibility. What about the teacher who comes back from a technology workshop with an innovative program they want to test out?

Flexibility and Compromise Needed

Like with any group of people, all teachers are not the same when it comes to technology expertise and needs. In recognition of the different users they serve, IT departments should consider giving their technologically progressive educators administrative rights to their classroom computers. This would permit them greater flexibility and power over their instruction, while still protecting the network. The decision about who gets more (or less) desktop control should be made on a case-by-case basis not just by the IT people, but by district administrators who fully understand teachers' instructional requirements.

At the same time, educators need to view IT support staff as partners in the educational enterprise, not enemies to teaching and learning. After all, the bottom line for district employees, whether classroom teachers or IT support staff, should be identical — to maximize learning opportunities for students.

Wesley Fryer, TechLearning.com's IT Guy columnist, is director of distance learning of the college of education at Texas Tech University.

Featured

Related

Desktop or Laptop?

Question: Do you recommend that school districts purchase desktop or laptop computers for teachers? The IT Guy says: At one time, desktop computers were far more powerful than laptops and a case could be made that laptops were simply too expensive and underpowered to be realistic for teacher purchases. Those

Remote Control

It's no secret that the combination of young people and computers can equal aimless Web surfing. In the classroom, teachers incorporating computers into their lessons need to make sure students are using technology in productive ways. To do this, many schools have turned to classroom management systems. Does your

Remote Desktop no longer works on my school computer

Question: I started to use WindowsXP several years ago, and I really liked the ability to use remote desktop to connect to my school computer from my home computer also running WindowsXP. Using the IP address and the same login information I use at school, I have been able to connect to my office computer’s

The world's largest desktop virtualization deployment announced

Userful, ThinNetworks, and Positivo announced their plan to provide 324,000 virtualized desktops to schools in all of Brazil's 5,560 municipalities—the World's largest desktop virtualization deployment. The Linux equipped desktops will be offered at a record setting low cost for PCs,

Cross-Platform Desktop Videoconferencing

Question: We have some teachers who want to participate in a project involving desktop videoconferencing. However they use Windows XP computers and the teachers with whom they want to videoconference are using Macintosh computers. Are there software solutions available which permit cross-platform desktop

Image placeholder title

Control Room

“When I came here last August, I wanted to use LANDesk, because I’d used it before and loved it,” says Rick DeLaunay, director of technology and media.

Remote Desktop Connection Error

Question: I am having trouble connecting to another Windows XP computer on our school network with the Remote Desktop Connection. I get the error "VBScript: Remote Desktop Disconnected." What should I do to make this connection? The IT Guy says: The first thing to do is make sure remote desktop connections are

New desktop speakers promo image

New desktop speakers

Califone  International, Inc., announces the launch of its new desktop computer speakers designed for classroom use.

Collaborate with Control

Built with educational users in mind, Revizr allows content creators students and teachers to upload documents for collaboration without losing editorial control. Invited collaborators offer suggestions for changes the suggestions appear as hand drawn markup.  Those who do have control