Web 2.0 Is All about 'Open'-- Except When It Comes to Data - Tech Learning

Web 2.0 Is All about 'Open'-- Except When It Comes to Data

At the Web 2.0 Summit, debate spins about on what the right approach is for customer data control.
Author:
Publish date:

Courtesy of InformationWeek Among the many Web 2.0 buzzwords, none has quite the cachet of "open." Yet no idea is more profoundly troubling to the companies trying to build profitable Internet businesses. With open standards, open networks, open source software, and open APIs, companies are trying to figure out how to be open without giving away the store. Speaking last week at the Web 2.0 Summit in San Francisco, Marc Canter, CEO of Broadband Mechanics, summed up the mood: "The challenge we have in the Web 2.0 world is to invent new kinds of lock-in." Data is the last lock-in. And it may not last long. Mobile phone companies used to deter customer defections by holding hostage 10 digits of data--if you wanted to change carriers, you left your phone number behind. In November 2003, the FCC put an end to that practice, letting customers shop around with their phone numbers in tow. For Web companies that try to hold on to customers by keeping their data, a similar fate may await, though not likely at the hands of regulators. None other than Google--which has profited enormously from the data users submit to its services and from the data its users generate through use of its services--is thinking seriously about how to give users more control over their data. Though stopping short of a complete data emancipation proclamation at the Web 2.0 Summit, CEO Eric Schmidt said, "The more we can let people move their data around ... the better off we'll be." Given AOL's recent blunder of releasing 20 million search queries--data it thought was anonymous but could be tracked to individuals in some cases--many Google users would no doubt jump at the chance to erase information about their searches from Google's servers. A German court last week ruled that people should be able to delete their data from ISPs in most cases, Spiegel Online reports. There's no sign that the old-school information industry--credit report companies such as Experian and data aggregators such as ChoicePoint--is on board. But Web startups and others are starting to discuss the extent to which their users should have control over data created by or about them. Options Open Back in April, Ian Davis, a developer and technical lead of the research group at library software vendor Talis, released a draft of the Talis Community License. Just as the Creative Commons License offers an alternative to conventional copyright protection and the GPL offers an alternative to software licenses, the TCL aims to describe a more flexible, Web-friendly set of database rights than the current legal default. On his blog, Tim Bray, director of Web technologies at Sun Microsystems, suggests that data portability is a prerequisite for services claiming to be open. "Any online service can call itself 'open' if it makes, and lives up to, this commitment," he wrote in July. "Any data that you give us, we'll let you take away again, without withholding anything, or encoding it in a proprietary format, or claiming any intellectual property rights whatsoever." At the Web 2.0 Summit, Marc Hedlund, co-founder of a financial information community startup called Wesabe, presented his company's "Data Bill of Rights," which includes the right for users to export or delete their data, as well as the assurance that user data is theirs and private. Wesabe needs to promote that kind of trust. It hopes to create a community of users who pool financial transaction data, such as anonymous credit card purchases, to sell insights it gleans from mining that data, such as the tendency of people to visit certain restaurants once and never return. Conference panelists pointed to Google Groups as a model of openness for user-generated data, since users can ask to have posts removed from Google's archives. What's the right mix of open, free, and profitable? Count on companies to struggle with that well into Web 3.0.

Featured

Related

Image placeholder title

All About the Data: Tech&Learning Live @SchoolCIO14 Summit

More than 50 chief informationofficers and superintendentsgathered at the IntercontinentalHotel in Atlanta, Ga. for twodays in June to discuss, debate,and commiserate about the mostprovocative topic in education technologytoday—student data and what to do withit.

Image placeholder title

All About the Data: Tech&Learning Live @SchoolCIO14 Summit

More than 50 chief information officers and superintendents gathered at the Intercontinental Hotel in Atlanta, Ga. for two days in June to discuss, debate, and commiserate about the most provocative topic in education technology today—student data and what to do with it.

Professional Development and Web 2.0

from Technology & Learning Professional development in most schools has a predictable look and feel: summer workshops, brown-bag luncheon trainings, and the infamous in-service day. These events can be successful, and there is no doubt they have helped numerous educators become better at what they do. But Web 2.0

It's All About Connections

In this month's cover feature, "Online Training: What's Really Working," page 32, author Kim Carter examines the latest developments and challenges connected with educating educators via the Web. Perhaps not surprisingly, the pros and cons of this delivery system remain essentially the same as those we flagged for

Web 2.0: A Guide for Educators

from Technology & Learning Web 2.0: What's all the fuss about? No one would dispute that today's Internet has become a pervasive influence on the daily lives of a significant number of citizens across the world. It quickly revolutionized the way we access information, conduct business, and find entertainment.

Web 2.0 Pocket Dictionary

from Technology & Learning Aggregator: presents feeds from multiple authors and content types (blogs, wikis, podcasts, Flickr, and del.icio.us) all in a single location for ease of processing. Blog: Web log or chronological online personal journal with reflections, comments and often links to other Web

5 Web 2.0 Time Savers

from Technology & Learning These applications can help busy administrators reclaim precious hours. Web-based productivity tools help people collaborate, communicate, and save time—and the good news is most are free. Below are five good strategies for using them. 1. Clean out your inbox and focus your