Uncertainty and ignorance: an issue for assessment?

Academic education can be summarised by the observation that it involves knowing more and more about less and less -- until you reach PhD level, where you know everything about nothing!
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
0
Image placeholder title

Ignorance vs certainty, by Terry Freedman

When I was studying Economics at school, I thought of myself as an economist. (I even put that down as my first choice of summer work when I was hoping not to actually be offered a job. My second choice was astronaut: I didn't get that either. I was offered a job as a sweeper in London Zoo. But I digress.)

By the time I'd completed a degree in the subject, I was aware of the vast expanse of ignorance opening up before me.

In fact, academic education can be summarised by the observation that it involves knowing more and more about less and less -- until you reach PhD level, where you know everything about nothing!

On a practical level, it makes setting multiple choice test questions very difficult -- because really clued-up students will often realise that at least two answers are equally viable, depending on the assumptions you make.

Read more.

cross-posted at www.ictineducation.org

Terry Freedman is an independent educational ICT consultant with over 35 years of experience in education. He publishes the ICT in Education website and the newsletter “Digital Education."

Featured

Related

A Few Thoughts on Standardized Testing promo image

The Checklist Approach to Assessment

“In undertaking project-based activities a good strategy that teachers may use is to create an observation recording sheet, which has been mapped against the relevant curriculum descriptions in advance, so that as a student is observed performing a skill, you can easily annotate the sheet to indicate what outcomes were achieved.”

Image placeholder title

Assessing Information Technology in 1995

Read on to find out what teachers were not expected to do, and marvel at the fact that today some people are still giving teachers poor advice about how to determine whether or not a pupil has reached a particular level of understanding.

The Trouble With Rubrics promo image

The Assessment Challenge

"What does this student know, what does she understand, and what can she do?" brings us right back to basics. It gets to the heart of why we do what we do in the first place.