PxPixel
Seattle’s invisible tech industry by Frank Catalano - Tech Learning

Seattle’s invisible tech industry by Frank Catalano

Having spent a February week at a major technology industry trade show, I was delighted to see key Seattle area companies well represented on the Austin exhibit floor.
Author:
Publish date:

Having spent a February week at a major technology industry trade show, I was delighted to see key Seattle-area companies well-represented on the Austin exhibit floor.

The 450 exhibitors included DreamBox, co-founded by a Microsoft veteran and now backed by Reed Hastings of Netflix; GlobalScholar, run by a former Amazon.com and Drugstore.com executive and recently purchased by Scantron; McGraw-Hill’s Center for Digital Innovation with its Planet Turtle virtual world; Qwizdom, one of the top players in hand-held devices showing its new QTopia digital environment; and several others.

If you live in Seattle you may never have heard of these local firms. Perhaps that’s because the conference was the Texas Computer Education Association 2011 conference, and the companies are among the many Seattle-area firms in education technology.

In a city where the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation makes headlines every time it talks about education reform or with the grants it issues in that arena, local companies actually providing the cutting-edge tools and digital technologies are virtually invisible. Not just to the general public, but to the tech community here as well.

As someone who has straddled both consumer and education technology markets over the past decade, I’ve been puzzled by this lack of awareness. It’s not just the companies who were at the Austin conference that have low local visibility, but other established Seattle area K-12 firms like Giant Campus and Apex Learning (both forces in online learning), Headsprout (K-5 reading instruction), and more. My conference litany didn’t mention every Seattle exhibitor. Even Microsoft had a small booth, focused on cloud computing and teacher professional development, though I’ve heard the bulk of its business lies in other markets.

Why does the ed tech industry have this unexpectedly low profile on the home turf of the Gates Foundation?

1) It is not easy to understand the market. Getting companies and products to K-12 school customers is a complicated and frequently convoluted mess. It combines the worst of government/B2B sales (differing state and federal regulations, long sales cycles) with the worst of consumer sales (finicky individual customers, be they educators or students). Plus, the terminology and products aren’t necessarily mainstream or part of our collective memory of our school years: adaptive web instruction, interactive white boards, classroom response devices (requiring one panelist at another recent conference to field the question from a puzzled parent, “What are they doing with their thumbs?”). Trying to succinctly communicate how it all works to an outsider is maddeningly complex, a puzzle-wrapped-in-an-enigma-sealed-in-an-egg-shape-to-be-celebrated-by-Lady-Gaga kind of complex.

2) Few venture capitalists understand the models. Not a lot of tech investors seem to truly understand how K-12 education business models work (even fewer than those who understand higher education business models). Those tempted to learn may lose interest when they hear, as was described at the recent Ed Tech Business Forum in New York City, that it’s a “get rich slowly” business. Still, some do, and a few high profile edtech acquisitions of late -- Wireless Generation by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp., GlobalScholar by Scantron -- seem to be increasing interest … and valuations.

3) Local industry support structure is missing. While there are national trade associations for education technology companies (such as the Software and Information Industry Association’s Education Division, which holds the aforementioned Ed Tech Business Forum), local technology trade groups never seen to have taken much sustained interest in edtech. The Washington Technology Industry Association, Northwest Entrepreneur Network and others have great general, horizontal efforts but no ongoing groups or initiatives that target education technology, unlike the occasional local focused efforts for energy (clean and green tech) and health care technology.

Remedying one, two or all three of these conditions would help local education technology companies’ profiles and may spur further growth and innovation in the Seattle area.

The solution may be organic, albeit long term. I’ve seen a dramatic narrowing of the gap between consumer and edtech expectations and products over the past few years as even young teachers can now wear the overused badge of “digital native.” Or it could be as simple and short-term as an existing local tech organization deciding this is worthwhile outreach (perhaps prodding a well-worded news release from a certain Microsoft founder).

But with school education reform increasingly on the national, as well as the Gates Foundation, agenda, it might be nice knowing who around here is trying to digitize it.

Frank Catalano is a Seattle-based consultant on marketing, branding and product strategy for education and consumer technology companies. He blogs at Intrinsic Strategy and tweets @FrankCatalano. This essay originally appeared on the Seattle technology news site TechFlash.com.

Featured

Related

Ed Tech Industry Network of SIIA Announces New Board of Directors promo image

Ed Tech Industry Network of SIIA Announces New Board of Directors

WASHINGTON (Dec. 16, 2015) – The Education Technology Industry Network (ETIN) of SIIA, the principal trade association representing the software and digital content industries, announces the new members of its ETIN Board of Directors. These newly elected and appointed executives from SIIA member companies represent a broad spectrum of corporate interests, and their visionary leadership will help guide the education technology companies during this time of industry change.   As board members, these individuals represent more than 200 ETIN member firms that provide educational software applications, digital content, online learning services and related technologies across the K-20 sector. The new board members will help develop initiatives and determine the projects, activities and events for ETIN in 2016 and beyond.

SIIA’s 2013 Annual Ed Tech Industry Summit Explains ‘Navigating Next’

The Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA), the principal trade association for the software and digital content industries, last week held its 10th Annual Ed Tech Industry Summit, themed “Navigating Next,” in San Francisco. Attended by more than 350 educational technology leaders, the Summit featured strategies, cases studies, and success stories about best business practices on topics including game-based learning, going global and mobile, market data and trends, OER and commercial publishers, leveraging social media, and more.

Ed Tech Industry Summit to Focus on ‘Navigating Next’

The 10th annual Ed Tech Industry Summit (ETIS), hosted by the Education Division of the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA), will be held May 5-7 at The Palace Hotel in San Francisco. ETIS is the nation's leading education technology industry conference, featuring content-rich sessions on the ed tech market and connecting industry executives through networking sessions.

Industry Leaders Forecast Areas of Growth During Education Business Forum promo image

Industry Leaders Forecast Areas of Growth During Education Business Forum

WASHINGTON (Dec. 22, 2015) – The Education Technology Industry Network (ETIN) of SIIA, the principal trade association representing the software and digital content industries, brought together K12 and higher education ed tech leaders during the Education Business Forum this month. ETIN provided attendees, including financial gurus and Innovation Incubator finalists, insights into the growth areas for technologies that will transform the education industry.ETIN reviewed and accepted 10 ed tech early-stage companies to pitch their innovative products to investors and acquiring companies attending the forum. The organization presented top awards to FANSchool, Inc. for Fantasy Geopolitics as the Most Innovative and MathSpace for MathSpace as the Most Likely to Succeed. 

CEV Multimedia Introduces Industry Partners, Online Certification Program

LUBBOCK, Texas (July 21, 2014) – CEV Multimedia, a leading producer of Career and Technical Education (CTE) curriculum resources, today announced the inaugural industry partners supporting its new certification program during a news conference in Austin, Texas. State Representative Jimmie Don Aycock, Chair of the House Committee on Public Education and author of Texas House Bill 5, joined the industry partners at the event in support of CTE initiatives.