Cleveland, Ohio: Peter Robertson - Tech Learning

Cleveland, Ohio: Peter Robertson

As CIO for the Cleveland Municipal School District, Peter Robertson developed a data warehouse, launched an online report card system, and managed a 75 percent reduction in IT support costs while keeping service levels high.
Author:
Publish date:

As CIO for the Cleveland Municipal School District, Peter Robertson developed a data warehouse, launched an online report card system, and managed a 75 percent reduction in IT support costs while keeping service levels high. Now on leave to pursue a doctorate at Teachers College, Columbia University, we got him to pause long enough to share some war stories.

Q: Many K–12 districts are beginning more and more to resemble their corporate counterparts in terms of automation. At the same time, studies have questioned the value of computers in the classroom. What do you see as the role of IT in the school?

A: IT has multiple roles, but the one that we’re really grappling with is making sure that our IT investments are improving efficiency in the organization. Particularly in the 20 percent to 30 percent of the organization that has nothing directly to do with the classroom, technology should be doing precisely the same things it does in the corporate sector, namely, providing 2 percent to 3 percent productivity gains year in and year out. IT should free up resources, not consume them, so we can focus on the other, more important role of technology, which is to improve the effectiveness of the teaching and learning process.

The fact that we have not yet seen substantial gains in educational effectiveness through technology precisely mirrors the problem that business has had. For 20 years, businesses invested in technology with minimal obvious benefit. As Larry Cuban has pointed out, it’s really hard to get classroom processes redesigned to take advantage of technology. It’s not going to be easy, but I’m convinced that it can happen; it’s happening in some places, and that needs to remain the priority of technology in schools.

Q: From your experience, would you say K–12 IT operations are generally efficiently run? If not, what are the biggest areas where you can see room to work more effectively?

A: Let me start by saying that I’m not an expert in this area, but my general sense is that K–12 IT is not particularly effectively run. There are a number of very difficult challenges, and the biggest one involves the recruiting, ongoing development, and retention of highquality people. IT people are knowledge workers, and knowledge workers play by different rules than more scrutinized work employees. Teachers are knowledge workers, too, but they lock themselves into one particular industry, while IT staff can go wherever the job is and are very mobile. K–12 IT workers need to be motivated differently—not only with a different salary schedule, but also by making a heavy investment in ongoing professional development. Much of the problem that schools have in this area has to do with good people whose skills are generations old. In IT, whether K–12 or elsewhere, you have to keep the skill sets current.

In Cleveland, I got lucky. The Y2K boom was over, the tech bubble burst, and for a while I could pick up IT workers cheap. This past spring, however, I lost a lot of good people, many of whom could get 50 percent better pay elsewhere. They weren’t necessarily out looking for better pay, but they got frustrated with our inability to promise security and professional growth in a time of crisis. We can’t offer top dollar, but we at least need to find ways to let knowledge workers keep their skills sharp and their careers growing, or they will not stay.

The answer to this, at least for larger school districts, is to build a farm system: have a very skilled group of managers, a well-documented set of work processes, and bring in less-expensive workers who can cut their teeth on the excellent technical challenges and opportunities in the K–12 environment. Many will leave in a few years, and that’s fine, as long as there’s good management in place to allow for effective transitions.

For more of Peter Robertson’s thoughts, including his perspectives on open source and wireless, read the expanded version of this interview at www.techlearning.com/schoolcio.

Featured

Related

Plain Dealer

DEK: As CIO for the Cleveland Municipal School District, Peter Robertson developed a data warehouse, launched an online report card system, and managed a 75 percent reduction in IT support costs while keeping service levels high. Now on leave to pursue a doctorate at Teachers College, Columbia University, we got him

Peters Township School District

Name: Peters Township School District Peters Township School District provides educational services to K-12 students in McMurray, Pennsylvania. The purpose of the district Website is to provide a wide variety of helpful information to the community and staff. The site has a consistent look and feel, making it easy

Ohio schools add wind energy, save thousands per year

 Like many K-12 districts, Perkins Local Schools in Sandusky, Ohio, contended with an outdated and inefficient infrastructure. The district’s boiler plant dated back to the 1920s, for instance, and needed an overhaul. Numerous building envelope repairs were required to prevent air loss.

Ohio districts sign 10-year WAN deals

Unite Private Networks (UPN) announced today its agreement to provide data services over a fiber optic Wide Area Network (WAN) for Elyria City and Perrysburg Schools in Ohio.

World of Peter Rabbit

World of Peter Rabbit This official Beatrix Potter site has information about her life, work and art as well as fun games to play with the characters. It also includes a text resource which relates people and events from Potter's life to characters and events in her stories. Frederick Warne & Co.