Study: E-Learning Implications - Tech Learning

Study: E-Learning Implications

The good people of NCREL, the North Central Regional Educational Laboratory, have come up with a “meta-analysis” on the effects of Distance Learning in K-12, and I’m not sure whether their study is incredibly validating – or a total disaster. A meta-analysis is a study of a bunch of
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
0

The good people of NCREL, the North Central Regional Educational Laboratory, have come up with a “meta-analysis” on the effects of Distance Learning in K-12, and I’m not sure whether their study is incredibly validating – or a total disaster.

A meta-analysis is a study of a bunch of studies. Essentially, NCREL examined every respectable study on the effects of Distance Learning – any kind of Distance Learning – over the past five years and boiled them down to 14 that met all their criteria. Those 14 studies yielded “116 independent effect sizes drawn from a combined sample of 7561 students” (you can read the meta-analysis at “The Effects of Distance Education on K-12 Student Outcomes”. Their performances were compared to a control group of non-Distance Learning students.

Most of the students in the studies were in secondary school; the classes were either synchronous or asynchronous, or some combination; the classes were held five days a week, or not. In short, the study reviewed a wide variety of Distance Learning practices, with very different affordances.

The study does go through a series of caveats before stating their conclusion. It’s only one meta-analysis, after all. One must remember Piaget and of course Vygotsky. Some subject matter, like complex math, doesn’t quite work in a Distance Learning format. And we need more information.

But the study does have a conclusion, however tentative: “The analysis resulted in an overall weighted effect size not significantly different from zero…distance education is as effective as classroom instruction.”

My problem is, considering my deep antipathy to traditional classroom practice, I’m not sure whether the conclusion is good news or bad news. Another way of putting the results of the study is that nothing matters. Whatever educational choice you make – whatever technology (if any), and presumably pedagogy as well, it doesn’t matter. The students will do about the same no matter what – those who come to school motivated to learn and expecting to succeed by and large will, and those who don’t, by and large won’t. This implies that, if we want to change educational outcomes, we’re looking at the wrong end of the horse – instead of focusing on schools, teachers, pedagogy, and technology; we should be focusing on the much more difficult problem of the culture of poverty.

And we all know how likely that is.

Now I realize I’m jumping to conclusions; I’m going far, far beyond what the authors of the study state; E-learning is in its infancy and can get much better; and I really can’t believe the argument I’m making anyway (otherwise, what have I been doing all these years?). However, I know a simile that frightens me:

For decades, people would pay big money to big shrinks who would listen to their patients for years, helping them with their day-to-day anxieties. Scientists and some academics in the psychology community complained that no form of analysis was scientifically based, and therefore couldn’t possibly be affective.

Well, the research was done, and it turns out that there is no difference between a long, expensive analysis with an Ivy League psychologist, or regular visits with a social worker, or frequent chats with a good friend.

In other words, psychoanalysis is bunk.

Are we just like psychoanalysts?

Why don’t you stretch out on my couch and we’ll talk about it. But I’ve only got an hour…er, fifty minutes…..

Craig Ullman

Featured

Related

E-Learning Gets Real

from Technology & Learning Call it virtual, distance, or online education. For today's curricula, it's no longer a question of whether or not to try but when to start Our survey of educators who already use these technologies can help the uninitiated. When does an idea evolve from faddish to

Shaping E-Learning Policy

Cody Millin is nine-and-a-half years old and looks like a typical fourth-grader, but he's in sixth grade and has no trouble doing the work of a typical middle school student. He does all of his learning from home and likes working independently. He says, "I'd get bored waiting for others to finish an assignment. I

Study: Interactive whiteboards boost pre-school learning

The first research to study the use of interactive whiteboard technology in preschools appears to show that the SMART Board™ solution developed by HATCH® – the TeachSmart® Learning System – can be used successfully with preschool children to affect student gains in core early literacy and math skills.

Study: Interactive technology aids learning promo image

Study: Interactive technology aids learning

A two-year study released today supports the use of effective teaching practices combined with interactive classroom technologies to boost student academic performance, according to the study sponsor Promethean Ltd.

Case Study: Learning With Tablet PCs

Choosing the Right Tools Bishop Hartley has long been a technically savvy learning institution where it is believed that a student’s opportunity to learn is enhanced by greater mobility and greater access to information. Our students are used to a mobile environment. To utilize this mobility, students need

Online learning study looks at research promo image

Online learning study looks at research

Online learning is one of the fastest growing trends in educational uses of technology, according to the recently-released report from the U.S. Department of Education, Office of Planning, Evaluation, and Policy Development.

Life and Learning in the E-Bubble

Technology advancements have included an evolution of software, hardware, electronics and more. This discussion focuses on the future of those advancements and their effects on the way we will live. I sit in my chair with a keyboard in my lap and an optical mouse on my side table. I watch my screen as I work: a

Online learning study looks at research

Online learning is one of the fastest growing trends in educational uses of technology, according to the recently-released report from the U.S. Department of Education, Office of Planning, Evaluation, and Policy Development.

Study: ATOS an effective measure of text complexity

Renaissance Learning announced today that ATOS, the readability formula incorporated in the Accelerated Reader program, was found in an independent study to be a valid, reliable measure of text complexity as required by the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) for English Language Arts.