9 Challenges of Project-Based Learning

10/16/2013 12:00:00 AM

Although I am an advocate of project-based learning, I am not unaware of its challenges. As the old military adage has it, failure to prepare is preparation to fail, so here is a list of what I consider to be the main issues you need to be aware of. Many of them may be subsumed under the general heading “management”, but I believe it’s worth itemising them all nonetheless.

Coming up a rich problem

This is a key issue. As we saw in 7 Reasons to use project-based learning in computing, a “rich” problem has many potential dimensions. “How can we make the roads safe around here?”, the example given in that post, has no simple, cut and dried answers. For example, one reason that kids get knocked over by traffic is that they step out into the road while texting or listening to music. Another reason is that children find it hard to judge the speed and distance of oncoming vehicles. Those are not easy problems to solve. On the other hand, a “problem” like “What’s the climate like in New Mexico” can be solved in about two minutes, simply by looking it up.

You don’t have to come up with the problem yourself. Staff, parents and pupils themselves can be invited to make suggestions, based on the things that are worrying them. The list they come up with should keep you in projects for quite a while!

Monitoring who is doing what

I mean this in two senses. First, you need to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to develop the same skills. Not necessarily in one project, which would be asking a lot, but certainly over the course of the year. Otherwise you could have a situation in which a pupil only ever does writing or design work, and never touches data handling, for example. Think of the individual pupil outcome as a patchwork quilt: it doesn’t work if all the squares are the same colour.

Second, if one is not careful, it is very easy to allow some pupils to get away with doing very little. However I think one needs to be both pragmatic and perceptive.


I once had a class for two hour lessons, twice a week. If I saw a couple of pupils taking a break to discuss last night’s soap, I took the view that as I can’t work for two hours solid, why should I expect them to be able to? But after a few minutes I’d catch their eye and point to the clock. That was all that was needed.


Some pupils look like they are not doing any work at all. But just because you can’t see their brain whirring doesn’t mean that nothing is going on. In one group I had, one boy spent virtually all group discussion time talking about football with his friends on the next table. But every once in a while he would lean over, and make a suggestion. The others invariably followed this new lead, and it was also invariably a brilliant idea. So who is to say he wasn’t working, just because he didn’t demonstrate it in the usually accepted manner? This, of course, raises another issue arising from PBL….

Assessing accurately

If 5 people are involved in a project, how do you assess each of them on the quality of the outcome? You could decide to simply give them all the same mark. I think that is unfair, or potentially so. I preferred to do three things in this regard:

  • Monitor who did what, and keep a written record of that;
  • Have the pupils themselves log what they did at the beginning and end of each lesson;
  • Talk to pupils individually to find out if they really do know what they ought to know if they have done the work they said they had.

Monitoring progress

This is related to assessment, but is not quite the same. What I am referring to is the fact that you need to ensure that each pupil is improving, which entails being challenged. Hopefully, pupils are not doing the same sort of thing in every project, but if they do end up working in the same area twice, the second time should be a development rather than a repetition.

Providing catch up opportunities

If a pupil misses a particular type of opportunity, how will you ensure that s/he makes up for it? This relates to the points about monitoring: if a pupil has been involved in 4 projects, say, over the course of the year, and has not once touched computer programming in all that time, you may have to tell him what role he is going to take on in the next project. Hey, if it’s good enough for Lord Sugar to do that on The Apprentice, it’s good enough for me!

Ensuring no time is wasted at the start of the lesson

You want the start of the lesson to be dynamic and purposeful. The pupils want that too. What you really don’t want is 30 kids all shouting “What do I have to do?”. The best way to ensure a proper start of the lesson is to allocate time at the end of each lesson for planning. Pupils should note down the following:

  • What they have done during the lesson;
  • What they need to get on with next lesson;
  • What they need to do between now and then in order to be able to just get on with it as soon as the doors are opened next time.

I have adopted this approach with even the most challenging of classes. It works.

Ensuring quality learning

There’s learning, and there’s quality learning. So-called peer learning is not much good if the person you’re teamed up with has the same misconceptions or same lack of knowledge as you do. You need to:

  • Monitor what goes on in the lesson, so you can provide timely assistance when required (see next point);
  • Make sure you know who the class experts are, so you can send pupils to them as necessary. For example, one of the pupils might be the “go-to person” for spreadsheet modelling or video editing. If they are, take advantage of the fact;
  • Have a set of resources (books, handouts, useful websites) that you can direct kids to when appropriate.

Ensuring nobody waits too long for assistance

What do you think is an acceptable “wait” time? Personally I believe that 5 minutes is too long. You need to have a range of strategies that you can employ, to ensure pupils are not hanging around waiting for you to answer a question. For example:

  • A rule like “Ask three and then me”.
  • Having lots of useful resources for kids to explore for assistance;
  • Clear instructions on the whiteboard, or the wall;
  • Over the long term, establish a classroom culture of “If I can’t get on with what I want to do, I’ll get on with what I can do.”. There is always something useful that a pupil can be getting on with;
  • Having the ability to talk to one person while scanning the rest of the room helps too!

Not minding an air of organised chaos

If a project is something the kids can really get their teeth into, and there is a sense of excitement, even urgency, then forget about the idea of a British Library type of atmosphere. It’s going to be a bit noisy, and at any one time kids will be walking about getting resources, talking to other pupils or printing stuff out. If that’s something you find hard to handle, or difficult to explain to a visiting inspector, then maybe PBL is something you should avoid.

cross-posted on www.ictineducation.org

Terry Freedman is an independent educational ICT consultant with over 35 years of experience in education. He publishes the ICT in Education website and the newsletter “Computers in Classrooms."

comments powered by Disqus


The National Basketball Association (NBA) and Discovery Education...

Measured Progress Awarded Contract for Maryland High School Assessments

DOVER, N.H.—April 26, 2017—The Maryland State Department o...

IO Education Earns Two BESSIE Awards from ComputED Gazette

ATLANTA – April 24, 2017 – IO Education, a market leader i...

Fuel Education Reimagines Credit Recovery Curriculum to Motivate Students to Stay on Course

Designed for the “at-promise” student who needs to earn cr...

myON Named Best Digital and Media Literacy Solution by the Association of American Publishers

The personalized literacy solution was selected as a 2017 REVERE Award...

T&L Partner Post
Photo GalleriesView All Galleries >
Acer C720-2844 Chromebook

(www.acer.com) The Acer C720-2844 Chromebook model delivers speedy performance, a quick boot time of seven seconds, and a matte anti-glare display tha...

Britannica ImageQuest

(www.britannica.com) Britannica Digital Learning has upgraded ImageQuest, a resource for schools and libraries that provides nearly three million rig...


(www.classflow.com) Promethean has released ClassFlow, a free, all-in-one, cloud-based teaching tool that lets teachers create and deliver interactive...

Adobe Voice

(www.adobe.com) Adobe has released Adobe Voice, an animated video app for the iPad that lets users create and share video stories. The app incorporate...


(www.boxlight.com) The BOXLIGHT DeskBoard mobile cart adjusts both height and tilt for the P8 ultra short throw interactive projector on a white surfa...

Core 36M

(www.bretford.com) Bretford has introduced Core 36M, a 36-unit charging cart that is optimized for Chromebooks but which also supports most tablets, l...

Edmentum Sensei

(www.edmentum.com) Edmentum Sensei is a mobile optimized solution that helps administrators visualize and track overall school, teacher, and student p...

HMH Player

(www.hmhco.com) HMH has released HMH Player, a new native app for iOS and Google Chrome that streamlines the learning experience for improved digital ...

Juice Power System

(www.bretford.com) Bretford has unveiled an easy-to-use modular power system with exchangeable power components. The Juice Power System uses unique &#...


(www.lightsailed.com) LightSail Education has announced a literacy accelerator that combines books with in-text embedded assessments and real-time dat...


(www.myon.com) myON has expanded its digital library to include a set of literacy tools to further personalize the reading experience for students whi...

Nervanix Clarity

(www.nervanix.com) Nervanix has released Clarity, an application that monitors student attention levels as they study and guides them to revisit conce...


(www.robotslab.com) RobotsLAB has introduced MathBall, a smart sensor basketball and tablet system that offers curricula in algebra, pre-calculus, phy...


(www.waspbarcode.com) Wasp Barcode’s MobileAsset.EDU solutions include everything administrators need to account for their assets, from software...

OpenEd Assessment Creation Tool

(www.opened.io) OpenEd has announced a free tool that lets teachers easily create assessments with the question types required by Common Core standard...

Panasonic TH-80LFB70U

(www.panasonic.com) Panasonic’s TH-80LFB70U interactive LED display features high-speed, multi-touch, interactive capabilities to promote partic...

penveu interactive display system

(www.penveu.com) The penveu interactive display system is a handheld device that turns projectors and large screen displays into interactive whiteboar...


(www.califone.com) Califone has updated its PresentationPro speaker. The PA310 readily connects with computers, LCD projectors, mobile devices, intera...

PowerSync+ Mobile Companion App

(www.bretford.com) Bretford Manufacturing, Inc. has announced the availability of the companion app for its PowerSync+ enabled charge and sync produc...

PureCharge Carts and Stations for iPad

(www.bretford.com) Bretford Manufacturing, Inc. has debuted the PureCharge family of iPad and iPad mini charging carts and stations. By offering pre-i...

ProQuest Research Companion

(www.proquest.com) ProQuest’s new information literacy product, Research Companion, offers videos that guide users through the research process,...

Sphere2 & Class Send Student Engagement Software Platform

(www.averusa.com) AVer Information has developed a Student Engagement platform, providing teachers and students with the tools to transmit document ca...


(www.averusa.com) AVer has released the TabChargeCT2 charge cart solution, which can hold up to 40 Chromebooks, iPads, Android or Windows tablets, lap...

VoiceLift with Instant Alert and Emergency Video Monitoring

(www.extron.com) The Instant Alert function of the Extron VoiceLift Microphone, combined with a PoleVault, WallVault, or PlenumVault classroom AV sys...

SMART Board 6065

(www.smarttech.com) The SMART Board 6065 is an ultra HD, 4K interactive flat panel that offers collaborative capabilities while ensuring lessons run s...

Gaggle Unity Partner Program

(www.gaggle.net) The new Gaggle Unity Partner Program provides free data integration services for all educational technology vendors. Through the Gagg...

Waterford Early Learning, Reading, Math & Science

(www.waterford.org) Waterford Early Learning Cloud can be used at home or to supplement lessons in classrooms. It can also be used for individual adap...

NetSupport School

(www.netsupportschool.com) The latest version of NetSupport School allows teachers to monitor and collaborate with any mix of technology. An enhanced ...


(www.techsmith.com/camtasia) TechSmith’s Camtasia gives teachers the tools to record lessons, create videos, and engage their audiences. Educato...

Panasonic 3E

(www.panasonic.com) Intel has teamed up with Panasonic to announce the Panasonic 3E, which uses the Intel Education 2-in-1 reference design. Designed ...